If one wanted to accuse civilization of being uncivilized, one would want to accuse France. So here we go, a youth culprit of repeated deliberate criminal driving is killed by police while trying to run down police… Thus, France is racist! … declares a chuckling plutocratic establishment.
OK, granted, it may not have been smart for a police officer to lean down on a car he had been trying to stop for 15 minutes… But try that one in the USA…
Angel Nahel, was chased by officers on motorbikes through red lights for 21 minutes, speeding in the bus lane with an expensive Mercedes AMG. Ironically he zoomed through the Rond Point des Droits de l’Homme (Place of Human Rights), the Pablo Nureda boulevard (Neruda was a dedicated communist Nobel)… Nahel was below driving age. He always drove without insurance. And had been arrested for these infractions before. The officers had called for backup. Nahel nearly crushed a pedestrian and a cyclist. Blocked by a traffic jam on Boulevard Arago, he decides to ignore the two oficer who have their guns out, and crash on place… Nelson Mandela. Arago, famous for the Arago dot, was an early theoretician of the wave theory of light and polarization, proving that the vibration of light was transverse to wave propagation, discovering and explaining rotary polarization, eddy currents, etc. Later he became an influential Member of Parliament, revolutionary, and minster of war of the French republic (1848).
So Nahel’s crazy, potentially murderous driving, tore through a landscape labelled with great minds.
And why was Angel Nahel so keen to drive hyper dangerously and not obey orders from the police to stop his criminal activity? Because in France, philosophically idiotic judges think they help young people by letting them live criminal lives. Not that this absurd legal philosophy, that the law shall not be legal anymore, depending how you look like, is specifically anymore French. The philosophy that the law is unjust and illegal developed in France, festered there for 35 years, and now spread to the USA.
Pamela Price, County District Attorney in Alameda County, San Francisco Bay Area, explained exactly why (she is a friend of mine, by the way). She claims it’s because she used to be a criminal herself and had she been severely imprisoned, she would have become this wealthy lawyer with a mansion in the hills (I have been there), not elected as chief enforcement officer of a powerful and wealthy county of 1.7 million people, residence of the mightiest public university in the world, UC Berkeley, and birthplace of Tesla, with the only Tesla factory in the world for 15 years and countless high tech companies. Also with curious tent cities below freeways.
Pamela and her ilk have created such a nice environment that recently there was a running gun battle at Pier 39, the exact heart of tourism in California. In California, tourists don’t need to watch movies of the old West anymore, they can learn to duck during real gun battles. OK, I am being unfair. One of the shooters came from Contra Costa County, just north of Alameda.
Nahel was shot once in the arm… AFTER he floored the powerful sport car with two police officers hanging at the car’s window, and AFTER the car he was illegally driving moved forward.
The anti-police forces argued that shooting in such a case is legal only if the police officer was in front of the vehicle. Instead the anti-police fanatics argue that the officer was not in front of the car, but sideways, it was just a matter of having his foot crushed, and allowing Angel Nahel to pursue his joy ride in Paris. However, we have videos.
The officer said he fired because he was afraid that a member of the public was going to be hit by the car. The procureur of the republic said conditions for usage of a gun were not found.
The officer, after a 15 minute chase, was leaning forward, with his elbow and chest on the car. His colleague was by the car window. The two existing videos will be examined frame by frame. Yet the fact there are two videos is itself ample testimony that Nahel deliberately refused to obey the officers, even after he had threatened the civilian population by his reckless driving for 15 minutes, and the scene was dramatic enough for at least two different persons to film the confrontation.
A passenger of the AMG declared that Nahel confused brake and accelerator. Why didn’t Nahel turn the car off as he was ordered to do? From a feeling of impunity or omnipotence? I can drive at very high speed through a city of ten million people because I am a special angel subjected to blatant racism against children driving at reckless speed an expensive sport car that 99.9% of the French population can’t afford?
It is not clear that the tragedy, in the end, was not an accident, caused by martyr Nahel himself as the acceleration shock of more than half a g… So martyr Nahel pedal action would be what pulled the trigger… thus justifiable homicide. The car was wrecked by the subsequent crash. There was no toddler in the way of Nahel’s criminal driving, fortunately.
The officer, an ex-soldier, is highly decorated. So Macron, calling the shooting “Inexcusable” may have himself contributed to the insurrection, by throwing gasoline on the fire. Macron should go to law school. For the basics.
Macron does not seem to know that the more you excuse, the more you get. Marine Le Pen, the main opponent figure to Macron, and twice finalist to the French presidency, is a lawyer. She pointed out that Macron, who is France’s top legal officer, should let justice do its work. Macron is not a lawyer. i
***
UN Anti-French Intervention:
The UN wants you to know France is a bad, “deeply racist” country. Yes, “deeply racist”. No wonder everybody in Africa wants to go to France! To enforce racial justice! But a new army of half a million Africans invading France every year is not enough! More anti-racist Africans are needed to invade France and punish the colonists at home!
Indeed, the UN human right commissioner said the UN rights office (OHCHR) said it was time for the country to reckon with its history of racism in policing. In Geneva on Friday, OHCHR Spokesperson Ravina Shamdasani expressed concern over the death of 17-year-old Nahel M on Tuesday, after he was shot dead driving away from a traffic stop in the Parisian suburb of Nanterre.
“This is a moment for the country to seriously address the deep issues of racism and discrimination in law enforcement”. “We also emphasize the importance of peaceful assembly. We call on the authorities to ensure use of force by police to address violent elements in demonstrations always respects the principles of legality, necessity, proportionality, non-discrimination, precaution and accountability., she said.
She called for any allegations of disproportionate use of force by people exercising their rights to protest, to be swiftly investigated.
According to latest figures released by France’s police regulator, there were 37 deaths during police operations recorded in 2021, of whom ten were shot dead. By comparison, there are more than 150 homicides in the small city of Oakland, California, population 400 K, in one typical year. In the US, nearly 1,200 were killed by police in 2022, the most ever. That’s per capita around 10% of France.
Does that mean, Ms Sham, that the US is ten times more racist than France? Because you seem to call any police killing “racist”. I don’t know if you know, but Martyr Nahel was “white”.
In India around 2,000 people were killed by the police in 2022. Moreover nearly 200 “terrorists” were officially killed. Jammu and Kashmir Police has called the year 2022 a very successful one in anti-terror operations in the Kashmir region. The police informed that 172 terrorists have been killed in over 90 operations in the Kashmir Valley.
Ms Sham is from India, where, frankly and naturally, human rights are less respected than in France. It pales relative to the US or where Ms Sham is from… Speaking of racism, is that overreaction to the Nahel tragedy not anti-French racism? Yes, and I think it’s even anti-civilizational, as it makes fun of reason itself: France may be racist, indeed, but the rest of the world is worse. Reason is at the root of optimal civilization.
***
Actually the problem of France is the exact opposite of what Ms Sham pretends to be: there is not enough repression in France. And not just repression of wayward youth, but repression of an ideology which sent 7/11, yes seven elevenths, of the French economy to China and its ilk. What people like Nahel deserve is not money from drug trafficking and speeding through Paris in hyper expensive sports cars, but decent jobs…
On this, giving youth decent jobs, the US scores higher than the other major countries of the West (with a 3% unemployment rate, a third of France). Of course a very long story, and not necessarily a pretty one. The US is a jungle and headquarters to world plutocracy. Biden adopted Trump’s Make America Great Again policy, with even bigger means (as Republicans kept voting for MAGA, now Biden’s push!)
But the US also has kept its industrial base. One reason is the US Defense Industrial Base: enormous defense spending, and related activities (aerospace, electronics) has kept a gigantic subsidized industry. I criticized Obama for enabling Elon Musk to become all he wanted to be (by financing Tesla and SpaceX)… But it worked for the better… In particular SpaceX, a sort of privatized NASA, succeeded to do what NASA long tried to do: build a road to affordable space. Now Spacelink is making a difference in Ukraine, battling Putin’s orcs… When one looks around the US, most cars one sees are built in the US, even… BMWs… And if not built in the US, built in NAFTA (improved by Trump in a US sense), that is in the satellites of Canada and Mexico…
***
It is madness to train the youth to not ever obey the police, as the French pseudo-progressive establishment and the judges it mentally corrupted, seem to believe. It is madness to let the same youth thrive from drug trafficking. Better do what California did, and legalize pot (although DUIs can be given for pot driving, not just alcohol).
Making the youth mad is no way to help them.
Want to help young people? Give them jobs.
Contrarily to repute the amazing US economy is greatly regulated and greatly state financed: it is just below European radar.
California financed Tesla; Alameda County financed Tesla, and enabled Musk to bend laws; the US Federal State organized gigantic subsidies to Tesla from traditional car makers…
Instead what has France subsidized? Retirees. 17 million well paid retirees in France, for 23 million full time workers.
Well, guess what France? Learn your own history, the most bellicose history anywhere. Retirees don’t win wars.
And winning wars are what history is made of, and superior civilization is all about.
Yes I am not really sorry that the supporters of enslaving ideologies had to read that.
Patrice Ayme